In our line of networking – for over 42 years now, it is surprising how often many Ethernet Extension troubleshooting performance issue are attributed to crappy RJ-45 head crimps.
Of course the AT&T starLAN topology that brought us RJ-45 LAN networking has only been around since the early 90’s.
Today’s 802.3 Ethernet cabling is critical for ensuring stable network performance regardless of 2-pair (10/100Mbps) or 4-pair(1G,2.5G and 10G) speeds. The telecom technology of Ethernet Extender and PoE extenders do not require any twisted pair wiring and rather the more copper the better for communications – it is still critical to ensure solid crimps for connections.
When troubleshooting we have seen quite often problematic performance issues being attributed to wiring structure not being crimped correctly even though cables have been certified and passed testing like with high and low end Fluke LAN test tools of a basic Volt meter for continuity. Higher end Fluke Cable IQ tools for detecting classes of PoE power are widely trusted for testing cable integrity, professionals often find themselves re-crimping RJ-45 heads to improve reliability and performance. So, why re-crimp after passing the test? Let’s explore the reasons, challenges, and best practices for ensuring optimal connectivity.
Understanding Fluke Meter Testing
Fluke Networks is renowned for producing industry-standard cable testing tools, often used to certify Ethernet cable installations. These tools are capable of performing a wide range of tests to ensure network cables meet performance specifications, from basic continuity checks to advanced diagnostics. Passing a Fluke test means the cable should theoretically function as intended. However, passing the test doesn’t always account for real-world factors that can impact long-term network reliability.
Key Tests Performed by a Fluke Meter
A Fluke meter tests several aspects of cable performance to ensure optimal functionality:
- Wiremap Test: This checks the correct wiring configuration of the Ethernet cable. It detects common wiring issues such as open circuits, shorts, miswiring, and split pairs. A cable that passes the wiremap test should have all conductors in their correct positions, but this doesn’t guarantee a perfect crimp or long-term stability.
- Insertion Loss (Attenuation): The meter measures how much signal is lost as it travels down the length of the cable. Excessive signal loss can degrade network performance, especially over longer distances. While passing this test shows acceptable signal strength, it doesn’t consider subtle weaknesses in the RJ-45 connector that could cause long-term performance degradation.
- NEXT (Near-End Crosstalk): This test measures interference between cable pairs, which can degrade data transmission. High crosstalk often results in slower network speeds or intermittent connection issues. Passing this test shows the cable meets the minimum standards for crosstalk but doesn’t eliminate the potential for issues caused by improper crimping or environmental changes over time.
- Return Loss: This measures the amount of signal reflected back towards the source. High return loss can indicate poor termination or physical damage in the cable, which could lead to performance issues. While a pass here signals no immediate concern, subtle imperfections in the crimp or cable positioning within the RJ-45 head may still lead to future problems.
- Propagation Delay & Delay Skew: These tests measure how long it takes for a signal to travel through the cable and the difference in signal arrival times between pairs. Consistency in signal arrival is important for synchronized data transmission, especially for high-speed networks. Flaws in the crimping process, like excess untwisting of pairs, can affect delay skew, leading to performance inconsistencies down the line despite passing initial tests.
Limitations of Fluke Testing
While Fluke meters provide a comprehensive diagnostic for cable testing, they do have limitations. Even if a cable passes all of the key tests, the result may not account for other important variables that impact the real-world performance and durability of the RJ-45 connection:
- Mechanical Integrity: Fluke tests primarily measure electrical performance, not the physical integrity of the connection. A cable could pass testing but still have a weak or insecure crimp that becomes problematic over time due to mechanical stress (e.g., bending, pulling, or vibrations). The mechanical aspects of the crimp (pressure, wire alignment, and contact precision) are crucial for longevity, and these are factors a Fluke test may not detect directly.
- Environmental Factors: Fluke tests are typically done in controlled environments, but the actual installation may be exposed to temperature changes, humidity, and electromagnetic interference (EMI). These environmental conditions can negatively affect the crimped connection over time, causing intermittent connectivity issues even if the cable originally passed Fluke certification.
- Connector Quality: The quality of the RJ-45 connectors used in an installation can vary significantly. While a Fluke meter can confirm that a signal is being transmitted correctly, it doesn’t evaluate the materials or precision of the connectors themselves. Cheap or low-quality RJ-45 heads might pass the test but fail prematurely due to poor pin alignment, weak clamping, or inadequate insulation.
- Subtle Cable Issues: Sometimes, cables have imperfections or inconsistencies that are too small to be detected by a Fluke test but still affect performance in the long run. These issues may only become evident after sustained use or under specific conditions like heavy data traffic or high-temperature environments.
Why Re-crimp RJ-45 Heads Despite Passing Tests?
Passing a Fluke meter test typically gives professionals confidence in the electrical integrity and performance of an Ethernet cable. However, the decision to re-crimp RJ-45 heads even after a successful test is driven by various factors related to real-world application, long-term reliability, and mechanical stability. Here are several key reasons why re-crimping is often necessary despite an initial pass:
1. Intermittent Connectivity and Network Fluctuations
One of the most common reasons for re-crimping an RJ-45 connector is intermittent connectivity, where network devices drop connection or experience fluctuations in speed. This issue can persist even when a cable has passed a Fluke test, because the test is a snapshot of the cable’s condition at a given moment. Intermittent issues are often caused by:
- Loose Wires Inside the Connector: The individual copper conductors inside the RJ-45 connector may not be fully seated or securely pressed against the pins. Over time, slight movements in the cable can cause these wires to lose contact, leading to temporary disconnections or speed drops.
- Pin Misalignment: Although the Fluke test doesn’t detect this immediately, the alignment of the gold-plated pins inside the connector is crucial. If the crimp isn’t tight or precise enough, pins may not make solid contact with the cable’s copper wires, resulting in intermittent signal disruptions that appear later during normal use.
2. Poor Initial Crimping Techniques
Even if a cable passes a Fluke test, the initial crimping job may not be up to standard. Poor crimping techniques are common when installers:
- Fail to Use the Correct Tools: Using substandard or poorly maintained crimping tools can result in an uneven or insufficient crimp. A cable may pass a basic connectivity test but still have loose or poorly seated connections within the RJ-45 head. Over time, this can lead to problems, especially in environments where cables experience frequent movement or vibration.
- Over- or Under-Crimping: Excessive force can damage the cable and the RJ-45 connector by deforming the pins or crushing the wires. Conversely, insufficient force during crimping may not create a strong enough connection, leaving wires loosely seated. Both scenarios can cause failures that manifest after the initial test.
3. Long-Term Durability in Harsh Environments
Many Ethernet installations are exposed to harsh or dynamic environments where cables endure stress that isn’t accounted for during a Fluke meter test. Some factors include:
- Temperature Variations: Fluctuations in temperature can cause materials to expand and contract. While a Fluke test in a controlled environment may pass, the cable and its connectors might experience degradation in more extreme settings. Re-crimping ensures that the connection is more secure and able to withstand such environmental pressures.
- Physical Movement and Vibration: Ethernet cables in dynamic environments, such as industrial settings or outdoor installations, are often subjected to constant movement, vibration, or tension. A connector that was initially functional may become loose or compromised after repeated stress. Re-crimping helps secure the connection against such mechanical strain.
- Exposure to Humidity and Dust: In environments where moisture or debris is prevalent, there’s an increased risk of corrosion or contamination at the connection points. Re-crimping the RJ-45 head with a proper seal and using high-quality connectors designed for harsh environments can mitigate this risk, even after the cable passes initial testing.
4. Maintaining Optimal Signal Transmission
While passing the Fluke test confirms that a cable meets basic standards, subtle issues in the crimp can still degrade signal quality over time. Some of these issues include:
- Excessive Untwisting of Pairs: For optimal performance, the individual twisted pairs in an Ethernet cable should remain twisted as close to the RJ-45 connector as possible. If the pairs are untwisted too far during the crimping process, it can cause slight degradation in signal performance, which the Fluke test might not detect immediately. Re-crimping with attention to maintaining proper twist ratios can help ensure minimal signal loss.
- Crosstalk and Electromagnetic Interference (EMI): A poor crimp can increase susceptibility to crosstalk (signal interference between wire pairs) and EMI (interference from external electronic devices). While Fluke testing checks for crosstalk, it may not always catch minor imperfections. Re-crimping can reinforce the shielding and contact points, reducing interference in high-EMI environments.
5. Addressing Connector Wear and Tear
The RJ-45 connectors themselves are prone to wear and tear, especially when cables are frequently unplugged and replugged. Over time, this mechanical action can weaken the connection or cause pins inside the connector to shift, bend, or lose contact. Even if a cable initially passes a Fluke test, repeated use can degrade the connection quality. Re-crimping the RJ-45 head, especially with a high-quality connector, ensures the pins remain in firm contact with the copper conductors, reducing the likelihood of future failures.
6. Oxidation and Corrosion
Over time, the copper conductors in Ethernet cables and the metal pins in RJ-45 connectors can oxidize, leading to poor conductivity. In humid or polluted environments, this process can accelerate. Even if the cable passed a Fluke test at installation, oxidation or corrosion may later cause issues such as:
- Increased Resistance: Oxidation increases the resistance in the circuit, which can reduce the signal quality and cause slower data transmission or packet loss. Re-crimping ensures that fresh, clean contacts are made between the copper wires and the pins, restoring the integrity of the connection.
- Debris or Contamination: Dust, dirt, and other debris can interfere with the contact points inside an RJ-45 connector. Even if this isn’t immediately noticeable during testing, it can accumulate over time. Re-crimping with clean, high-quality materials can prevent contaminants from affecting the connection.
Re-crimping RJ-45 heads, even after a successful Fluke meter test, is an essential step to guarantee long-term network reliability. Factors like mechanical stress, environmental exposure, and signal integrity all come into play, making re-crimping a proactive approach for ensuring consistent and durable Ethernet connections. In dynamic and harsh environments, ensuring optimal crimp quality can make the difference between a reliable connection and one that causes recurring issues.
Best Practices for Re-crimping RJ-45 Connectors
Re-crimping an RJ-45 connector requires attention to detail, proper tools, and a clear understanding of how to ensure a solid and reliable connection. When done correctly, re-crimping can fix performance issues, extend the lifespan of cables, and ensure consistent connectivity. Here are the best practices to follow when re-crimping RJ-45 connectors:
1. Use High-Quality Tools and Materials
The quality of the tools and materials used during the re-crimping process directly impacts the final result. Invest in high-quality crimping tools, connectors, and cables to avoid future problems.
- Crimping Tool: Use a professional-grade crimping tool designed for RJ-45 connectors. A good crimping tool will apply even pressure to all the pins, ensuring a reliable connection. Avoid using generic or inexpensive tools that may not create a secure crimp, which can lead to loose connections or poor contact between the wire and the pins.
- Connectors: Choose high-quality RJ-45 connectors, preferably shielded ones if the cable is exposed to electromagnetic interference (EMI) or in a noisy electrical environment. Make sure the connectors are designed for the specific cable type (e.g., stranded or solid conductor) and gauge (AWG) you’re using.
- Cable Tester: After re-crimping, use a cable tester or a Fluke meter to verify that the connection is stable and meets the required performance standards.
2. Strip the Cable Carefully
Before re-crimping, you must strip back the cable’s outer sheath to expose the internal wires. This step is critical, and any mistakes during stripping can result in performance issues.
- Avoid Nicking the Wires: When stripping the cable, be careful not to cut or nick the individual copper wires. Damaged wires can lead to signal loss or complete failure over time. Use a dedicated cable stripper that allows for precise cutting of the cable’s outer insulation without damaging the internal wires.
- Leave Enough Length: Strip just enough of the outer jacket to expose the twisted pairs but ensure you leave enough length to properly seat the wires in the connector. Typically, about 1 inch (2.5 cm) of exposed wire is sufficient for most RJ-45 connectors.
3. Maintain Pair Twisting
Maintaining the integrity of the twisted pairs is crucial for minimizing crosstalk and ensuring the cable’s performance, especially at high speeds like Gigabit or 10 Gigabit Ethernet.
- Minimize Untwisting: Untwist the wire pairs only as much as necessary to fit them into the RJ-45 connector. Excessive untwisting can introduce crosstalk and degrade the signal quality. Ideally, the twist should be maintained as close to the connector as possible.
- Stagger the Pairs (For Stranded Cables): For stranded cables, you may consider staggering the untwisted wire pairs to fit them more securely into the connector. This technique can help prevent wires from slipping out of place during crimping.
4. Proper Wire Alignment
Aligning the individual wires in the correct order is essential to ensure the cable’s performance. There are two standard wiring schemes for Ethernet cables: T568A and T568B.
- Use Consistent Wiring Schemes: Ensure that both ends of the cable use the same wiring scheme (either T568A or T568B). Inconsistent wiring will result in a non-functional cable. T568B is more commonly used in networking environments, but it’s important to verify which standard applies to your specific installation.
- Flatten and Straighten the Wires: After untwisting and arranging the wire pairs in the correct order, flatten and straighten them out before inserting them into the RJ-45 connector. This ensures that all the wires make solid contact with the connector’s metal pins.
5. Insert the Wires Correctly
Once the wires are properly aligned and straightened, carefully insert them into the RJ-45 connector. Each wire should go all the way into the connector, making solid contact with the appropriate pin.
- Ensure Full Insertion: Double-check that each wire reaches the end of its respective slot in the connector. A common mistake is leaving a wire slightly short, which can result in intermittent connectivity or complete failure. You should be able to see the copper wires through the transparent plastic tip of the connector when fully seated.
- Confirm Wire Alignment: Before crimping, visually inspect the alignment of the wires inside the connector. Make sure that none of the wires have shifted out of order or failed to make contact with the metal pins. Even minor misalignments can lead to functional issues.
6. Perform a Proper Crimp
Once the wires are properly seated in the RJ-45 connector, the crimping process is crucial to secure the connection.
- Apply Even Pressure: When crimping, ensure that even pressure is applied across the entire connector. A high-quality crimping tool will provide uniform pressure to all the pins, ensuring they pierce the insulation of the wires and make solid contact with the copper conductors inside.
- Check for a Secure Crimp: After crimping, inspect the connector to ensure that the pins are fully seated and have made a solid connection with the wires. There should be no loose wires or gaps between the pins and the connector.
- Re-crimp if Necessary: If the crimp isn’t tight or secure enough, or if any wires appear to be out of place, re-crimp the connector before testing. It’s better to take extra time now than to face issues later.
7. Test the Connection
After re-crimping the RJ-45 head, testing the connection is a critical final step to ensure that the re-crimping process was successful.
- Basic Continuity Test: Use a basic continuity tester to ensure that each wire is properly connected and the signal flows correctly through the cable.
- Advanced Fluke Testing: For more detailed diagnostics, use a Fluke meter to test for factors such as crosstalk, insertion loss, and return loss. This will help confirm that the re-crimped cable meets performance standards for your specific application, whether it’s for data transmission, PoE, or high-speed networking.
8. Label and Document the Cables
Once the re-crimping process is complete, label the cables for future reference. This is especially important in larger installations where multiple cables are running through walls, ceilings, or server racks.
- Cable Labeling: Use durable, clearly marked labels to identify the cable’s location, purpose, and connection points. This will save time in future maintenance or troubleshooting.
- Document the Process: Keep a record of any changes made during the re-crimping process, such as the use of new connectors, wiring schemes, or special crimping techniques. This documentation can be helpful for other technicians or when revisiting the network installation in the future.
By following these best practices for re-crimping RJ-45 connectors, you can significantly improve the durability and reliability of Ethernet connections. Proper stripping, wire alignment, crimping technique, and testing ensure that cables perform optimally, even in challenging environments. Taking the time to re-crimp and test cables correctly can save hours of troubleshooting and maintenance down the line, ensuring the network remains stable and efficient.
Final Thoughts and Conclusion
Re-crimping RJ-45 connectors, even when cables pass Fluke meter tests, is a proactive measure that can prevent potential issues down the road. While passing a test might indicate that the cable is functioning at the moment, the long-term reliability and performance of the connection depend on the physical integrity of the crimp. Factors such as poor wire alignment, inconsistent contact pressure, or environmental stresses can degrade a connection over time, leading to intermittent failures, signal loss, or performance bottlenecks.
By carefully re-crimping connectors, you address potential weaknesses before they become costly issues. For professionals working in high-performance environments—whether it’s a data center, industrial network, or residential installation—the cost of re-crimping pales in comparison to the potential downtime or troubleshooting costs caused by unreliable connections.
Key Takeaways:
- Prevention over cure: A cable may pass an initial test but can still fail later due to improper crimping. Re-crimping ensures longevity and performance.
- Attention to detail is key: Small misalignments, untwisting errors, or improper tool use can compromise the entire network. Following best practices ensures that every connection is solid and reliable.
- Comprehensive testing: Even after re-crimping, always test the connection to ensure compliance with performance standards, especially in critical environments.
Ultimately, re-crimping should be considered a key part of any thorough installation or maintenance process. It helps guarantee that your network operates at its peak, avoiding costly reworks, interruptions, and frustrations down the line. Taking the extra time to ensure a flawless connection with proper tools, methods, and testing is a best practice that pays off in the long run.
Extend any Ethernet Cable Beyond the Limits with Enable-IT Solutions !
The benefit of buying an Ethernet Extender from Enable-IT because our equipment leverages high throughput telecom signals over any wire – including coax, barbed wire fence, etc. Enabling distances unheard of in the industry. There are Ethernet Extender Solutions available that can extend this distance limit out to 9,000 feet or 2,743 m.
The industry uses are endless – as everyone has a need for extended Ethernet many times in their lifetime and sooner than later the need will arise and we are ready when you are to help select a solution.
Diverse Industry customers include the US, UK and Canadian Military; NASA; Aerospace manufacturers; Nautical Infrastructure (Marinas, Mega Yachts, Cruise Ships,Port facilities, US Nuke sub fleet, etc); Video Surveillance and Security Specialists; Advanced Telecommunications companies; Extreme Mining Operators; Global Construction Enterprises; Commercial Agriculture companies; major Healthcare providers; Live Entertainment, Broadcasting, and News agencies; Extreme Retail/POS organizations; Long-Distance Education Companies; International Hospitality Companies; Elevator manufacturers, Digital Signage and much more.
